Average rating 8.36585365853658 out of 10 ( based on 41 reviews )

Nice taste no support

Review by Miguel B. on 4/27/2009

Pros: Waited for a while to brew I keep asking for whole hops but they send me rabbit food. Whole hops are the best. I asked for whole hops. Maybe better response now

Cons: none adress my needs

too fruity

Review by Brett W. on 5/17/2009

Pros: easy to make

Cons: I thought this had too much of a poor imitation watermelon flavor I think that the amount of flavoring should be cut back and use only half of the bottle. I even let the beer sit in the keg for a month before trying it.

Too sweet

Review by Craig B. on 5/25/2009

Pros: None.

Cons: Overwhelmingly sweet, artificial watermelon taste. Not "beer-like". Low carbonation, flat. (I'd go for 1/2 the recommended watermelon flavoring added before bottling).

William's Watermelon Ale

Review by Kris E. on 8/5/2009

Pros: Crisp, somewhat light, popular with 99% of friends that tried it, nice carbonation.

Cons: The watermelon extract smells and tastes somewhat artificial at first. I think it ages well within 2-4 months it tastes more natural.

Watermelon Ale

Review by John L. on 8/11/2009

Pros: I don't know what every one is complaining about? this is a GREAT summer Ale. I used half the flavoring in my secondary fermenting "carboy" and the other half when I kegged this beer. I aged this beer for about three weeks in my carboy and two weeks in the keg and it turned out fine.

Cons: It's almost too easy to make, not much of a challenge here.

Write a Review